ホームブログ地絡用MCCBとRCCB:どちらの保護が必要ですか?

地絡用MCCBとRCCB:どちらの保護が必要ですか?

公開日時: 2026-11-15

ある購入者が「地絡保護」に関する2件の見積書を受け取りました。1つは複合保護機能を備えた成形ケース遮断器向け、もう1つは別途設置する過電流保護装置と組み合わせて使用することを想定したRCCB向けです。この仮想的な比較においては、機器単体の価格が低いからといって、回路に必要な全体の構成について十分な判断材料にはなりません。.

本質的な違いは 地絡用MCCB対RCCB 選択は保護範囲です。適切に設定された漏電遮断器(MCCB)は、公表されている過電流保護機能と残留電流保護機能を兼ね備えています。漏電遮断器(RCCB)は、一体型の過電流保護機能を備えていません。いずれも、回路の電圧、負荷、残留波形、感度および故障条件に適合させる必要があります。.

MCCBおよびRCCBは、どのような故障から保護しますか?

MCCBは、モールドケース回路遮断器を意味します。漏電保護機能付きのタイプには、公称過電流保護に加えて、所定の残留電流脱扣装置が備わっている必要があります。その機能を有しない標準型のMCCBであっても、定格電流が大きく、あるいは電子制御装置を備えているからといって、低レベルの残留電流故障を検知できると想定してはなりません。.

RCCBとは、過電流保護機能を内蔵しない漏れ電流動作形遮断器を意味します。その定格電流は、規定の条件における許容通電容量を示すものであり、この定格によって当該機器が過負荷継電器として機能するわけではありません。したがって、設置にあたっては、当該RCCBと整合した適切な過負荷および短絡保護を別途設ける必要があります。.

RCBOは、定められた適用範囲内で、漏電保護と過電流保護を一体化した別の区分に該当します。テストボタンを備えたすべての機器をRCCBとして分類したり、複合保護機能を持つ機器をすべてMCCBであると仮定したりしないでください。製品の仕様書および完全な型式資料によって、その区分が明確になります。.

選択ポイント 地絡用MCCB RCCB
過電流保護 供給されたモールドケース式遮断器の動作を確認してください。 過電流保護機能を内蔵していません。別途装置を組み合わせて使用してください。
漏れ電流保護 実際の漏洩量およびその設定を確認してください。 宣言された残留応答および感度を検証する
過失責任の証拠 電圧ごとに指定された正確なブレーカー定格を使用してください。 該当する定格およびバックアップ保護条件を使用してください。
インストールの詳細 ポール数、中性線の有無、解放機能および取り付け方式を確認してください。 電柱、中性線、試験回路および協調保護を確認する
Check overcurrent protection separately — explanatory illustration

RCCB Backup Protection and MCCB Selection

An RCCB needs coordinated overcurrent protection. The correct upstream or associated device is not selected only by choosing a lower nominal current. Obtain the manufacturer’s coordination requirements and account for the installation’s prospective fault current and overload conditions.

Similarly, a combined-protection MCCB is not automatically a complete solution for every circuit. Confirm its supported leakage sensitivity, waveform response and time behavior. A convenient combined package is useful only if those functions meet the actual requirements.

Start with the circuit rather than the preferred housing. Establish the supply, load, conductor protection, earthing arrangement and required disconnection behavior. Then compare complete arrangements that satisfy the same duty. For background on setting flexibility and device selection, see the MCCB selection guide for coordinated feeders.

Division of circuits also matters. A single upstream residual-current device sees the combined residual behavior of the circuits within its sensing boundary. The design must address normal leakage, fault isolation and the consequences of an upstream trip. These are design decisions, not reasons to increase sensitivity settings until nuisance trips disappear.

Choose the complete arrangement — explanatory illustration

Residual-Current Sensitivity and Trip Delay

Two devices with the same nominal sensitivity may still have different waveform response or time behavior. Select these characteristics from the connected equipment and installation requirements. Electronic loads can make a generic statement such as “leakage protected” too vague for a purchase specification.

HSE describes the protective role of an RCD rated at no more than 30 mA in certain electric-shock situations, while warning that an RCD cannot protect against every type of shock. A device intended for another residual-current duty does not become equivalent merely because it is called an earth-leakage breaker.

Rated current and residual sensitivity are different ratings. One describes current-carrying duty; the other describes the residual operating threshold. Likewise, a residual making or breaking rating must not be mistaken for the sensitivity. Mixing these quantities can produce a technically plausible-looking enquiry for the wrong function.

Time-delayed and non-delayed versions also need separate consideration. Selectivity depends on the exact devices and their documented characteristics, not simply on putting a larger sensitivity value upstream. Check the permitted disconnection times and manufacturer coordination information before accepting a proposed delay.

Installed Cost of MCCB and RCCB Protection

A useful cost comparison includes the complete protective arrangement, panel integration and commissioning work. An RCCB quotation may require an additional protective device, while an earth-leakage MCCB quotation may require a particular release or accessory. Neither arrangement is inherently the cheapest for every circuit.

Cost or design factor Question for both proposals Document to retain
保護範囲 Which device provides each required function? Complete protection schedule
パネル統合 What space, connections and accessories are required? Exact mounting and connection drawings
故障時の義務 Which ratings and coordination conditions apply? Matched ratings and backup-protection information
稼働開始 What tests and equipment are needed? Manufacturer instructions and acceptance record

Industrial MCCBs are assessed within the relevant IEC 60947-2 context. RCCB documentation commonly refers to IEC 61008-1 within its scope. These standard references describe different product requirements; they do not establish that two proposed devices are interchangeable or that a particular product has an independent certification.

Retain declarations and evidence for the exact versions being purchased. If a table or brochure mixes model families, resolve the inconsistency before approving the design. The time spent obtaining a corrected schedule can avoid a much larger delay when the panel is ready for acceptance.

WLM6LY-250 and JC3R-125 Selection Requirements

The WLM6LY-250 earth-leakage MCCB page identifies thermal overcurrent and electronic leakage releases. It does not establish a complete sensitivity schedule for every offered version. Request the exact pickup, delay, waveform and alarm or trip configuration.

The JC3R-125 residual-current device page separately calls for coordinated overcurrent protection. It also lists different response and sensitivity variants. Those variants should be selected explicitly; a family-level list does not mean one delivered unit includes every choice.

  1. Allocate each required protection function to a documented device.
  2. Match sensitivity, waveform response and time behavior to the circuit.
  3. Confirm pole, neutral and test-circuit arrangements.
  4. Obtain ratings, coordination evidence and commissioning instructions for the complete proposal.

Compare complete arrangements, not product labels. W9 can be contacted with the circuit duty and documentation requirements so the offered configuration can be identified before the quotation is accepted.

Earth-Leakage MCCB and RCCB FAQ

Does an Earth-Leakage Breaker Also Protect Against Overload?

It detects the specified leakage condition and performs its declared action, usually tripping where that function is provided. Confirm whether the actual product includes overcurrent protection or needs a separate coordinated device.

When Does a Circuit Need a Two-Pole Leakage Breaker?

Use a supported two-pole version where its supply, switching and sensing arrangement matches the circuit design. Confirm the exact neutral and test-circuit requirements rather than selecting by pole count alone.

Can a Leakage Trip Identify the Fault Cause?

Insulation damage, moisture or another unintended conductive path can contribute to leakage. Normal equipment leakage and a fault must be distinguished through competent assessment; the cause cannot be identified from a trip alone.

Are ELCBs and Modern Residual-Current Devices the Same?

The term is still used inconsistently. Older voltage-operated ELCBs and residual-current-operated devices have different principles, so identify the actual equipment and applicable rules before making a replacement decision.

How Is an Earth-Leakage Protector Classified?

It is a general description rather than a complete product classification. Ask whether the device is an RCCB, RCBO, leakage relay or combined-protection MCCB, and confirm the declared functions.

Does Every ELCB Provide the Same Protection?

Its protection depends on the operating principle and supplied configuration. The name alone does not establish overload protection, sensitive shock protection or suitability for every residual-current waveform.

参考文献

The right choice is the arrangement whose complete protection can be demonstrated. Explore the W9 electrical-protection range and contact the team with your circuit details to request a matched proposal.